Fish oil vs flaxseed oil for dogs - which is better? Can one substitute the other? Is flaxseed oil beneficial to dogs? Read on to find out.
Last week a visitor to my site referred me to an article on another dog site. The article keeps touting the fact that flaxseed oil contains high quantity of Omega-3s and how much dogs can benefit from the oil. What the article fails to do is to mention all the caveats, leaving readers (including the visitor who referred me to the article) the impression that flaxseed oil is an excellent oil to be given daily to dogs.
The visitor asked me, "So can I give flaxseed oil to my dogs instead of fish oil?"
The answer is simply "No".
Here are the main reasons:
Unfortunately, the dogs' bodies are not effective when it comes to converting ALA to EPA and DHA. So if you feed flaxseed oil to dogs, chances are only very small amounts of EPA and DHA will be available to the dogs.
The problem is, too much Omega-6s is not good for our dogs. The optimal ratios of Omega-6 to Omega-3 range between 10:1 and 5:1.
Now, if we feed our dogs a commercial dog food (which in general is high-carb and grain-based) AND flaxseed oil, chances are the flaxseed oil will tip the balance and our dogs will have too much Omega-6s in the bodies.
But isn't it true that Omega-3 is anti-inflammatory? If so, then flaxseed oil should be good for our dogs, right?
Again, the Omega-3s that have anti-inflammatory properties are the EPA and DHA; so while the Omega-3s in fish oil are anti-inflammatory, the ALA in flaxseed oil is not.
Many holistic vets and pet nutritionists are of the opinion that flaxseed oil cannot substitute fish oil. To quote just a few of them:
"While flaxseed oil has been suggested as a substitute for fish oil, there is no evidence that it is effective when used for the same therapeutic purposes as fish oil." (Shawn Messonnier, D.V.M., author of The Allergy Solution for Dogs).
"Although flaxseed oil is often touted as a substitute for fish oil, new studies show it's not a reliable alternative and, in fact, can be harmful. According to the study published in 'American Journal of Clinical Nutrition' flaxseed oil is found very less effective against inflammatory conditions." (Paul Jacobson, Pet Food Nutritionist).
"...flaxseed oil provides limited benefits for most dogs, although it may help with dull, dry coat in some dogs... No plant oil can replace the need for fish oil (or fatty fish) in the diet." (Mary Straus, in an article published in the Whole Dog Journal, November 2012).
"In feeding experiments, dogs receiving only flaxseed oil and commercial pet food suffered from bone and skeletal problems. When fish oil replaced the flaxseed oil, these problems disappeared." (C.J. Puotinen, author of Natural Remedies for Dogs and Cats).
"Due to the slow and low conversion rate of ALA to longer-chain omega-3 PUFA, and the lower effectiveness of ALA in maintaining normal neurological function in the healthy dog and cat, it seems prudent to pursue a more direct approach. The value of supplementation with fish oil to obtain presumably therapeutic levels of EPA and DHA is increasingly recognized." (Dr. Jennifer Larsen, 2011 ACVIM national meeting presentation - http://www.vscsturbridge.com/detailed-look-omega-3-fatty-acids/)
"Although ALA can be converted to EPA, which can then be elongated to DHA, in dogs the conversion of ALA to EPA is less efficacious than providing dietary EPA. For DHA this effect is even more pronounced than for EPA, since the conversion rate is even lower." (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3213045/)
As you can see, on the surface, the cheaper flaxseed oil may seem like an attractive alternative to the more expensive fish oil, but if you investigate further, you will realize that it is not so simple!
It is commonly agreed that flaxseed oil can improve the coat and skin conditions of some pets.
So yes, flaxseed oil does have some limited benefits for dogs.
How about lignans in flaxseeds? Aren't lignans beneficial to dogs? You may ask.
Lignans are beneficial (e.g. to dogs with Cushing's disease, or even for cancer prevention), but pure flaxseed oil does not contain lignans! Lignans are found in the flaxseed hulls. If you want to give your dog lignans, you should get flax hulls, instead of flaxseed oil.
*If you want to know more about the various benefits of essential fatty acids for dogs, see this page.